This home on approximately 3.2+/- acres in Sag Harbor is nestled into the Elizabeth Morton Wildlife Refuge (Sag Harbor's bird sanctuary). This is the only private property within the 187-acre sanctuary and is surrounded by it on three sides, with the Noyack Golf Course directly across the street. The Victorian era home built in 1890 has undergone a complete and sensitive renovation in 2019 that has retained and restored the home's period details while infusing state of the art 21st century amenities - an inspired synthesis of old and new. Enter from the wraparound front porch to stone-floored foyer and open first floor living areas with wide plank pine floors and beautifully detailed woodwork including multiple custom wood ceilings. The first floor comfortably flows among the living room, kitchen and dining area separated only by a double-sided fireplace. The kitchen with rustic granite topped counters and custom cabinets made from antique wood boasts high-end Bertazzoni appliances, central island with seating and rustic fireplace mantel. Two sets of French doors open to two separate patios from two sides of the kitchen. A large bedroom and full marble bath complete the first floor. Upstairs is the master suite with a wall of closets and luxe bath featuring double quartz-topped vanity, oversized shower with elaborate custom marble mosaic tile, steam and bench. Two more bedrooms share another marble bath with quartz-top double vanity and concealed stacked laundry. Off this floor is an expansive mahogany terrace overlooking the parklike rear grounds and refuge beyond. Outdoors enjoy the heated gunite pool with sun shelf, gardens, and a large shed set away from the house. A gate opens to a trail leading directly to the beaches on the peninsula surrounded by Noyack and Little Peconic bays. In addition, the owner will have access to the Noyac Hills Estates Association's 4-acre shared recreational property down the street with storage for kayaks and paddle boards, and the ability to launch and moor larger boats. This very special house is a rare jewel and a must-see.